Hi, my new Pietta engraved .44 is due to arrive tomorrow. I know many turn up their noses when considering the 1851 in .44 caliber. There however is one advantage with the .44 1851, 1860 .45 Colt conversion cylinders can be used with that revolver. I suspect that back in the day, with better metallurgy Colt would have manufactured their 1851 in .44 caliber.
We can lament about buying Italian reproduction not original, but nothing is original with replicas. The replicas have modern steel and we use BP subs not original in the day.
An 1851 shooting .45 Colt is a perfect revolver that still has linage to the past. It doesn't get any better.
Here is an 1851 that get it done:
![](http://i1283.photobucket.com/albums/a549/ssb73q/Mike1_zps66ba0d8e.jpg)
LeathersmithMikes holster also gives it great utility. I have a number of modern handguns, but would never feel underguned with this rig.
Regards,
Richard