Nor to a purist.
Absolutely. This from a guy who ignores Pietta billboards but everything else must be as historical as possible.
No 8" barrels on Pietta 1861 Navies, no Pietta 1861 Navy 4-screw revolvers CFS without the backstrap attachment aperture, no Pietta 1851 Navy shoulder stocks for a Navy 3-screw revolvers using a 2-headed hammer screw, no Pietta 1862 Pocket Navy .36 which is only based on a short-barreled Navy frame, no Pietta Dance .44 (modern production), no Pietta Pepperbox .36, et al.
This from a guy who has 8 different Pietta 1851 Navy "type" revolvers, mostly built using Pietta parts from VTI and Taylor's.
I want a new project: a Pietta 1851 Navy Dragoon .36 using a slightly cut down/shortened cylinder from a Pietta Pepperbox and modifying the barrel lug and forcing cone to fit. I have been in contact with Gary Barnes
http://www.cartridgeconversion.com/ and he thinks it is feasible. It won't be historical by any stretch of the imagination, but it will most likely be one of a kind. Stimulus checks will be here soon and I may be adding to the economy a bit doing this. If it comes to fruition I will start a new thread.
Regards,
Jim